Marketplace Review Team Forum
Permalink
I submitted an add-on for approval late last week. I had some questions about the process and status, but when I try to access the appropriate place for such discussion...
http://www.concrete5.org/developers/beta/marketplace-community-revi...
...I get a perpetual log-in page. I feel a bit "in the dark" as this is my first submission, and I'm unfamiliar with the process (aside from knowing it's a peer review process).
Will I be granted access to the above forum at some point, or should I pose my questions here?
Thanks,
-Steve
http://www.concrete5.org/developers/beta/marketplace-community-revi...
...I get a perpetual log-in page. I feel a bit "in the dark" as this is my first submission, and I'm unfamiliar with the process (aside from knowing it's a peer review process).
Will I be granted access to the above forum at some point, or should I pose my questions here?
Thanks,
-Steve
Additionally, emails should go out when comments are posted to your add-on. There have been two comments posted so far. You can also view them by going to edit your add-on and scrolling down.
Thanks Andrew,
I have received the emails (which were also sent to about 20 other folks - presumably the reviewers), so no problems there.
My main question is simply what the "typical" turn-around time is for the vetting process. I'm sure it varies with the complexity of the add-on and the time the reviewers have to devote to the task. I know they are all busy developers with schedules of their own; but not having been through the process before, I have no idea if we're talking 3 days or 3 weeks or what. I'm in no hurry - just curious about what to expect.
I was also curious about the "process" itself. The fact that it's a "peer review" process is the extent of my knowledge. If nothing else, I guess I'll learn as I go through it.
-Steve
I have received the emails (which were also sent to about 20 other folks - presumably the reviewers), so no problems there.
My main question is simply what the "typical" turn-around time is for the vetting process. I'm sure it varies with the complexity of the add-on and the time the reviewers have to devote to the task. I know they are all busy developers with schedules of their own; but not having been through the process before, I have no idea if we're talking 3 days or 3 weeks or what. I'm in no hurry - just curious about what to expect.
I was also curious about the "process" itself. The fact that it's a "peer review" process is the extent of my knowledge. If nothing else, I guess I'll learn as I go through it.
-Steve
Thanks for the reply, Mike.
> That forum is only for members on the PRB team...
If that's the case, then the following should probably be removed from the "review pending" (submission) page...
>> If you have any thoughts, gripes, or whatever about
>> this whole process, here's the forum to post them:
>> [link to] Marketplace Review Team Forum
While I didn't have any thoughts or gripes, I was going to check out the forum in an effort to familiarize myself with the process. That's all.
> just post your question here or in the comments
> section on the submission page.
Thanks, I wasn't sure if it was acceptable to post questions on that page. My questions have likely been answered before, so I was hoping to peruse a place specifically devoted to those kinds of questions.
> You will not be granted access unless you are on the PRB team
No prob. I'm not requesting access. It's just that the message I quoted above (on the submission page) implies that I should have access, hence my confusion.
Thanks again,
-Steve
> That forum is only for members on the PRB team...
If that's the case, then the following should probably be removed from the "review pending" (submission) page...
>> If you have any thoughts, gripes, or whatever about
>> this whole process, here's the forum to post them:
>> [link to] Marketplace Review Team Forum
While I didn't have any thoughts or gripes, I was going to check out the forum in an effort to familiarize myself with the process. That's all.
> just post your question here or in the comments
> section on the submission page.
Thanks, I wasn't sure if it was acceptable to post questions on that page. My questions have likely been answered before, so I was hoping to peruse a place specifically devoted to those kinds of questions.
> You will not be granted access unless you are on the PRB team
No prob. I'm not requesting access. It's just that the message I quoted above (on the submission page) implies that I should have access, hence my confusion.
Thanks again,
-Steve
just post your question here or in the comments section on the submission page.
You will not be granted access unless you are on the PRB team
Mike